C2C listener Andrew K. gave us a heads up to a fascinating story which was first reported in 1979. A Toronto man, while looking for a missing kitten, entered a cave where he encountered a furry creature of "unknown origin" that he described as "long and thin, almost like a monkey" with strange red eyes (sketched right).
You can read the original Toronto Sun news account at pararesearchers.org(1) who point out the creature's resemblance to the more recent Chupacabra.
1. http://www.pararesearchers.org/Cryptozoology/crypto1/crypto1.html